I heard this question raised on the radio today. Is Jimmy Smith a Hall of Famer. I am going to say no. He only has 67 touchdowns and that is i believe 37th all time. He never mosted more than 8 touchdowns in a season. And if you look at his contemporaries, people like Randy Moss who are already has more TD's and nearly as many recieving yards. Smith is playing in time where WR's are a strong position. If you look at the NFL today you have plenty of future HOFers. Moss, Owens, Harrison, Isaac Bruce, Torry Holt, Rod Smith. And Tim Brown, Jerry Rice, and Chris Carter are all headed to the hall of fame. I think he should be considered a canidate, but should not be in the Hall of Fame IMO.
|