Professor

I think Ellis did a great job to overcome his injury, but there were some that thought moss was still done, judging by his average draft position in fantasy, I really don't think anyone expected what he has done. I understand what you are saying, but it won't even be close in my opinion

__________________

BeastJacobs

The ONLY reason I think Ellis will beat out Moss. Ellis injured himself physically, and was aging Torn Achilles is a very serious injury and very few can come back and have a career year like he is having on it. Moss just had attitude problems and was sent to the black hole of Football called the Oakland Raiders. So, IMO he doesn't deserve it, he just doesn't like losing, and now he's on a winning team and decides to produce. So if that's you're only argument then the award should be Discontinued if Ellis doesn't win it.

__________________

gruntbygod

Moss probobly will win it, but it would be a total mockery for what the award stands for, like Shockey stated. I remeber Marcus Duoree got it before when he rushed for something like 200 yards or something in a whole season

__________________