gruntbygod

Mike Williams
Troy Williamson

__________________

Professor

this is tough to call, both have troubling QB situations, but minny's oline is a bit better right now and one thing BJ is, as long as the passes are not too far, is accurate. I don't think that minny will be relying on the pass unless they are down in games, so that will take away from williamson's numbers, plus aren't both guys at least third on the depth chart. I don't think either will be to good this year and I would imagine, even with his weight loss, I think it would be a smart move for Mike Williams to move to TE.

gruntbygod

Williamson will win the job in the preseason IMO.Mike could be a great possesion type (think Keyshawn) and with health concerns with Roy Williams, and with the variety of concerns with Rogers, Mike will find his way on to the field enough

__________________

WhatYa'Know'BoutThat101

Ummmmmmm...... out of the Williamson's I'm gonna have to go with Troy. Mike didn't have the season I thought he would have last year. I thought he would help them out alot but he only did it a little. He's still some help on the Lions and I think he will improve.

SicWithSkill

Troy has a qb.. We don't =X

__________________

WhatYa'Know'BoutThat101

I know we shouldve drafted Matt Leinart. We got all these good WR's but no good QB to back them up. Back me up on this one SicWithSkill.

Professor

all these good WR, like who, I'll give you roy, even though he has gotten hurt sometimes. Rodgers is a joke, williams is still young, but IMO too big to be a WR, even after his weight loss. After that who is there, don't even tell me scotty vines.

coldarmy20

Since it doesnt look like they'll be getting rid of him this year like i thought they would.. I am curious to see how rogers does in Martzs' offense. The best receiver this year will be roy williams.. not so sure about Mike Williams. I actually dont want them to move him to TE because we have plenty of tight ends right now. Pollard, Campbell, and Fitzsimmons will share duty, and I think we will be seeing some 2-tight end formations this year to help block. I doubt M Williams would be able to block whatsoever. Rogers and M Williams will be the wild card WR this year, trying to prove they deserve the starting spots. Id like to see how Bradford does this year if he starts.

__________________

coldarmy20

oh i mis-read the topic.. didnt know it was just between the two. I thought it was just asking who would be the best DETROIT WR this year. But between those two Id take Williamson.

__________________

MickeyG

i think Williamson will be better next year, but in the long run i can see Mike having the better career.

__________________