Thread Tools

Display Modes

danrc1985 · 11-12-2004, 10:07 AM

Who should I start?

Rattay vs Carlina DEF
A.Brooks vs Cheifs DEF

tregrimmd · 11-12-2004, 11:31 AM

Brooks fool hes one of the best QBs out there for this...scores TDs and yards, doesnt throw a lot of INTs, and can get you rushing stats...Brooks should always be the first option unless you have a Peyton or Culpepper...

Lego · 11-12-2004, 03:42 PM

Rattay. The Panthers will pull out to an early lead and the 49ers will be forced to throw early and often. He's less prone to turnovers and the Panthers D is not that much better than KC's.

tregrimmd · 11-12-2004, 04:23 PM

how exactly are the Panthers going to pull out to an early lead?

their RBs Stephen Davis, DeShaun Foster, He Hate Me, and WR Steve Smith are all out for the season...Brad Hoover is banged up...one of their OL just went out for the season...

star DT Kris Jenkins is out for the season, they wont be able to pass rush or stop the run as well...their secondary was never all that strong...they are a very weak team this season with all those injuries...Delhomme to Muhammad isnt strong enough to pull out ot an early lead...

Barlow should have a nice game...but id take Brooks over the Chiefs defense...Deuce is back, the passing game will be freed up...Horn, Stallworth, Henderson, Pathon, Boo...should put up some numbers against a weak KC defense...

and if thats not enough...Brooks is just a flat out better QB than Rattay at this point in time...

The Drake · 11-13-2004, 06:00 PM

Rattay, this really shouldn't even be a discussion. Brooks sucks.

MN 49ers Fan · 11-13-2004, 06:10 PM

Brooks easily. Rattay will have a bad game tomorrow against that Panthers defense. Besides our oline is still in schambles, so he'll be knocked around all day.