Dude236

My starting pitching is average at best, and this would significantly upgrade it, however it would be a big hit to my OF, as Beltran is my best OF and i think he will have a big year.


I give:
Carlos Beltran OF
Scot Shields RP/SP
Jason Schmidt SP

I recieve:
Aaron Rowand OF
John Smoltz SP
Roy Halladay SP


let me know what you think

__________________

sig by Pred

LTF

I'd probably do it. Beltran is not as big a fantasy guy as you think, neither is Rowad, b ut Beltran DOES have the edge. Smoltz >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Shields, other than the fact that Shields can be put as an RP or SP, and Halladay >>>>>>>>>> Schmidt

Dude236

ya your right smoltz and halladay smoke shields and schmidt, but rowand is a big downgrade, i think beltran will have a bounce back year. thanks for your input

__________________

sig by Pred

DHNF

Smoltz if he stays healthy this year will be a top 5-7 pitcher in MLB.

He has been working on a modified circle changeup this year and he's going to use the heck out of it. He has looked awesome this spring.

__________________

imported_Golden Hornz

yeah, cuz Roy Halladay > Carlos Beltran

__________________

</div><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1'><tr><td>QUOTE (J @ May 11th '06 @ 8:53 pm)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'> i have to **** HIM.* that way HE can tell ME what it feels like in HIS *******. </td></tr></table><div class='signature'>

imported_Falcons_rule

I'd do it.

__________________
<div align="center">

</div>

Dude236

the trade is going through unless some idiot vetos it

__________________

sig by Pred

LTF

Good deal for you, honestly IMO