vuch

Team A is in 4th place Team B is in 9th (10 Tm. league)

Team A gets Ben Roth. and Selvin Young from B

Team B gets Rudi Johnson and Jay Cutler from A

Fair or not?

Thanks.

Serrated Shadow

It depends, is this a PPR league or a standard league?

__________________

bigboy

The big question should be....fair to who?

Team B could be thinking Rudi will be breaking out of his funk and that Ben is not for real....

From a Commish standpoint, I dont and wouldnt see a problem with this deal.

__________________

vuch

Standard points league

bigboy

Why do you see the trade as not "fair"?

__________________

vuch

I see the team getting big ben as having the advantage. in our league right now Roth is the 4th ranked QB. Cutler is the 14th. He has 60 more points. The runners are within 2 points of eachother. Rudi will probably continue to share carries and Sevlin stands to have his workload increased when T. Henry gets suspended. The guy getting rudi and Cutler is way out of the competition this year.

Professor

looks fair to me

__________________

vuch

Thanks for the replies

bigboy

I can see your point but the guy getting ben doesnt get Ben's old games. He still has to show up after the deal and who knows if he will. If Rudi comes around (which may be what he's thinking) the deal may even work in his favor (Team B's)

__________________

footballforum33

Hi friend !
it it completely dependent on the performance of the team
in the ground and any comment before match is not fair .

__________________
I love footballforum