The First Number after the name is years played the second is pro bowls.
1936 Jay Berwanger, hb Chicago Philadelphia DNP -
1937 Sam Francis, fb Nebraska Philadelphia 4 0
1938 Corbett Davis, fb Indiana Clev. Rams DNP -
1939 Ki Aldrich, c Texas Christrian Chi. Cardinals 7 2
1940 George Cafego, hb Tennessee Chi. Cardinals 4 0
1941 Tom Harmon, hb Michigan Chi. Bears 2 0
1942 *Bill Dudley, hb Virginia Pittsburgh 9 3
1943 Frank Sinkwich, hb Georgia Detroit 4 0
1944 Angelo Bertelli, qb Notre Dame Boston Yanks 3 0
1945 *Charley Trippi, hb Georgia Chi. Cardinals 9 2
1946 Frank Dancewicz, qb Notre Dame Boston 3 0
1947 Bob Fenimore, hb Oklahoma State Chicago 1 0
1948 Harry Gilmer, qb Alabama Washington 2 0
1949 *Chuck Bednarik, c/lb Pennsylvania Philadelphia 12 8
1950 Leon Hart, e Notre Dame Detroit 8 1
1951 Kyle Rote, hb SMU N.Y. Giants 11 4
1952 Bill Wade, qb Vanderbilt L.A. Rams 13 2
1953 Harry Babcock, e Georgia San Francisco 3 3
1954 Bobby Garrett, qb Stanford Cleveland 1 0
1955 George Shaw, qb Oregon Baltimore 8 0
1956 Gary Glick, db Colorado A&M Pittsburgh 7 0
1957 *Paul Hornung, hb Notre Dame Green Bay 9 2
1958 King Hill, qb Rice Chi. Cardinals 12 0
1959 Randy Duncan, qb Iowa Green Bay 1 0
1960 Billy Cannon, rb Lousiana State Los Angeles 11 2
1961 Tommy Mason, rb Tulane Minnesota (N) 11 3
1961 Ken Rice, g Auburn Buffalo (A) 6 1
1962 Ernie Davis, rb Syracuse Washington (N) DNP -
1962 Roman Gabriel, qb N. Carolina State Oakland (A) 16 4
1963 Terry Baker, qb Oregon State L.A. Rams (N) 3 0
1963 *Buck Buchanan, dt Grambling Kansas City (A) 13 8
1964 Dave Parks, wr Texas Tech San Francisco (N) 10 3
1964 Jack Concannon, qb Boston College Bos. Patriots (A) 10 0
1965 T. Frederickson, rb Auburn N.Y. Giants (N) 6 1
1965 Lawrence Elkins, wr Baylor Houston (A) 2 0
1966 Tommy Nobis, lb Texas Atlanta (N) 11 5
1966 Jim Grabowski, rb Illinois Miami (A) 6 0
1967 Bubba Smith, de Michigan State Baltimore 9 2
1968 *Ron Yary, ot Southern Cal. Minnesota 15 7
1969 *O.J. Simpson, rb Southern Cal. Buffalo 11 6
1970 *Terry Bradshaw, qb Louisana Tech Pittsburgh 14 3
1971 Jim Plunkett, qb Stanford New England 15 0
1972 Walt Patulski, dt Notre Dame Buffalo 5 0
1973 John Matuszak, de Tampa Houston 9 0
1974 Ed 'Too Tall' Jones, de Tennessee State Dallas 15 3
1975 Steve Bartkowski, qb California Atlanta 12 2
1976 *Lee Roy Selmon, de Oklahoma Tampa Bay 9 6
1977 Ricky Bell, rb Southern Cal Tampa Bay 6 0
1978 *Earl Campbell, rb Texas Houston 8 5
1979 Tom Cousineau, lb Ohio State Buffalo 6 0
1980 Billy Sims, rb Oklahoma Detroit 5 3
1981 George Rogers, rb South Carolina New Orleans 7 2
1982 Kenneth Sims, dt Texas New England 8 0
1983 *John Elway, qb Stanford Baltimore 16 10
1984 Irving Fryar, wr Nebraska New England 15 5
1985 Bruce Smith, de Virginia Tech Buffalo 18 11
1986 Bo Jackson, rb Auburn Tampa Bay 4 1
1987 Vinny Testaverde, qb Miami, (Fla.) Tampa Bay 19 2
1988 Aundray Bruce, lb Auburn Atlanta 11 0
1989 Troy Aikman, qb UCLA Dallas 12 6
1990 Jeff George, qb Illinois Indianapolis 13 0
1991 Russell Maryland, dt Miami, (Fla.) Dallas 10 1
1992 Steve Emtman, dt Washington Indianapolis 8 0
1993 Drew Bledsoe, qb Washington State New England 13 4
1994 Dan Wilkinson, dt Ohio State Cincinnati 12 0
1995 Ki-Jana Carter, rb Penn State Cincinnati 8 0
1996 Keyshawn Johnson, wr Southern Cal. N.Y. Jets 10 4
1997 Orlando Pace, ot Ohio State St. Louis Rams 9 7
1998 Peyton Manning, qb Tennessee Indianapolis 8 6
1999 Tim Couch, qb Kentucky Cleveland 6 0
2000 Courtney Brown, de Penn State Cleveland 6 0
2001 Michael Vick, qb Virginia Tech Atlanta 5 3
2002 David Carr, qb Fresno State Houston 4 0
2003 Carson Palmer, qb Southern Cal. Cincinnati 3 1
2004 Eli Manning, qb Mississippi San Diego 2 0
2005 Alex Smith, qb Utah San Francisco 1 0
* Member of the Pro Football Hall of Fame
Number 2 picks
First number is years played second is pro bowls
1936 Riley Smith, b Alabama Boston Redskins 3 0
1937 Ed Goddard, b Washington St. Brooklyn Dodgers 2 1
1938 Jim McDonald, b Ohio State Philadelphia 2 0
1939 *Sid Luckman, qb Columbia Chi. Bears 12 3
1940 *George McAfee, b Duke Philadelphia 8 1
1941 John Kimbrough, b Texas A&M Chi. Cardinals 3 0
1942 Jack Wilson, b Baylor Cleveland (Rams) 3 0
1943 Joe Muha, b VMI Philadelphia 5 0
1944 Pat Harder, b Wisconsin Chi. Cardinals 8 2
1945 Paul Duhart, b Florida Pittsburgh 2 0
1946 Frank Dancewicz, qb Notre Dame Boston Yanks 3 0
1947 Fritz Barzliauskas, g Yale Boston Yanks 4 0
1948 Tony Minisi, b Penn N.Y. Giants 1 0
1949 Johny Rauch, qb Georgia Detroit 3 0
1950 Chuck Hunsinger, b Florida Chi. Bears 3 0
1951 *Y.A. Tittle, qb LSU San Francisco 15 6
1952 *Ollie Matson, b San Francisco Chi. Cardinals 14 5
1953 Jack Scarbath, b Maryland Washington 3 0
1954 Art Hunter, ot Notre Dame Green Bay 11 1
1955 Alan Ameche, b Wisonsin Baltimore 6 4
1956 Howard Cassady, b Ohio State Detroit 8 0
1957 John Brodie, qb Standford San Francisco 17 2
1958 Dan Currie, c Michigan State Green Bay 9 1
1959 Dick Bass, b Pacific L.A. Rams 10 3
1960 George Izo, b Notre Dame Chi. Cardinals 7 0
1961 Norm Snead, qb Wake Forest Washington (N) 16 3
1961 Tom Brown, g Minnesota N.Y. Jets (A) DNP -
1962 Roman Gabriel, qb North Carolina L.A. Rams (N) 16 4
1962 *Merlin Olsen, dt Utah State Denver (A) 15 14
1963 Jerry Stoval, b LSU St.L Cardinals (N) 9 3
1963 Walt Sweeney, e Syracuse San Diego (A) 11 9
1964 Bob Brown, g Nebraska Philadelphia (N) 10 6
1964 Pete Bethard, qb Southern Cal. Kansas City (A) 10 0
1965 Ken Willard, fb North Carolina San Francisco (N) 10 4
1965 *Joe Namath, qb Alabama N.Y. Jets (A) 13 5
1966 *Tom Mack, ot Michigan L.A. Rams (N) 13 11
1966 Rick Norton, qb Kentucky Miami (A) 5 0
1967 Clint Jones, rb Michigan St. Minnesota 7 0
1968 Bob Johnson, c Tennessee Cincinnati 12 1
1969 George Kunz, ot Notre Dame Atlanta 11 8
1970 Mike McCoy, dt Notre Dame Green Bay 11 0
1971 Archie Manning, qb Mississippi New Orleans 14 2
1972 Sherman White, de California Cincinnati 12 0
1973 Bert Jones, qb LSU Baltimore 10 1
1974 Bo Matthews, rb Colorado San Diego 8 0
1975 *Randy White, lb Maryland Dallas 14 9
1976 Steve Niehaus, dt Notre Dame Seattle 4 0
1977 *Tony Dorsett, rb Pittsburgh Dallas 12 4
1978 Art Still, de Kentucky Kansas City 13 4
1979 Mike Bell, de Colorado St. Kansas City 12 0
1980 Johnny 'Lam' Jones Texas N.Y. Jets 5 0
1981 *Lawrence Taylor, lb North Carolina N.Y. Giants 13 10
1982 Johnnie Cooks, lb Mississippi State Baltimore 10 0
1983 *Eric Dickerson, rb SMU L.A. Rams 11 6
1984 Dean Steinkuhler, g Nebraska Houston 7 0
1985 Bill Fralic, g Pittsburgh Atlanta 9 4
1986 Tony Casillas, dt Oklahoma Atanta 12 0
1987 Cornelius Bennett, lb Alabama Indianapolis 14 5
1988 Neil Smith, de Nebraska Kansas City 13 6
1989 Tony Manderich, ot Michigan State Green Bay 8 0
1990 Blair Thomas, rb Penn State N.Y. Jets 6 0
1991 Eric Turner, db UCLA Cleveland 9 2
1992 Quentin Coryatt, lb Texas A&M Indianapolis 9 0
1993 Rick Mirer, qb Notre Dame Seattle 12 0
1994 Marshall Faulk, rb San Diego St. Indianapolis 12 7
1995 Tony Boselli, ot Southern Cal. Jacksonville 7 5
1996 Kevin Hardy, lb Illinois Jacksonville 9 1
1997 Darrell Russell, dt Southern Cal. Oakland 5 2
1998 Ryan Leaf, qb Washington St. San Diego 3 0
1999 Donovan McNabb, qb Syracuse Philadelphia 7 5
2000 LaVar Arrington, lb Penn State Washington 6 3
2001 Leonard Davis, ot Texas Arizona 5 0
2002 Julius Peppers, de North Carolina Carolina 4 2
2003 Charles Rogers, wr Michigan State Detroit 3 0
2004 Robert Gallery, ot Iowa Oakland 2 0
2004 Ronnie Brown, rb Auburn Miami 1 0
aside from the fact that lookin' over these lists reminded me how old I am .you really can't say gallery is a bust,except for his first year in college he played left tackle.now the raiders in their infinite wisdom are keeping him at right tackle.to the uninformed not a big difference.but it's not his natural position.