imported_Blue Blooded

Lets hash this out. I'm settling an argument and I say Ben

vikinglady

Ben

__________________

imported_Blue Blooded

Lets see one QB has already proved himself and has the stats and record to prove it and the other is "hopefully" gonna be the best, no wait he definitely is gonna be the best one of these days...

MeatForSale

Ben... His fourth quarter stats from last year were extremely impressive... As were his first through third quarter stats. The team is obviously much better when he plays.

__________________

imported_Blue Blooded

You guys are viewing the this thread but not voting? just click

94SupraTT

Put Eli on a team with the #1 defense and that runs the ball 60% of the time and see how he does. The Steelers could not have made it any easier on Ben. Now thats not to say he hasn't played well because he has its just that the running game and D carried him last year much like Orton has been carried this year.

__________________
</div><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1'><tr><td>QUOTE (PeanutTillman)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'>Saturday Night I was just screwing around w/ a few frineds of mine playing w/ handbrake on a rainy pavement at 11 or so.So,we usually let er rip at around 35-40 just because I dont want my car blowed up.But I get a little cocky & say I can handle it @ 50.Umm..whoops.
</td></tr></table><div class='signature'>

Nixon

he pulled their asses out of the fire plenty of times too. Its a two way street. The defense and running game benefitted from Ben a hell of a lot too. His presence meant teams couldn't stack the box, and even if they did they'd get burned. He kept the offense on the field longer, this meant the defense wasn't out there as much getting exposed like they have at times this season without him. He changes the team more ways than just racking up stats. This is the way a lot of our "stars" on offense work. They don't pile on the numbers per se but their presence makes a definite difference. See: Dan Kreider, Hines Ward, and Alan Faneca. And yeah, I know Hines has put up some decent numbers but he's still considered by most as a 2nd tier receiver underneath Harrison, Owens and Moss.

And Eli's got Shockey, Barber, Toomer, Burress and a rebuilt O line. That's not a bad crew to have at your disposal.

__________________
CUNT SAUCE!!!

RipTheJacker

chargers made out the best!

__________________

TtTackler

Steelers, look at their win-loss record.

Eli needs to get out of his sophmore slump, but he has proven to be a capable comeback quarterback late in the 4th..

GoGiants98

you won't be able to settle this argument until both their careers are over. Until now it's been the Steelers, but who are we to say that the Steelers wouldnt be just as good with Eli at QB? Or the Giants just as bad with Big Ben? Big Ben could end up having a career ending injury the next time he takes the field(not likely and in no way do I hope for it at all) and the Giants obviously got more "bang for their buck", anything can happen

__________________

When Sean Avery was a child, he made his mother finish his vegetables.
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(Brooklyn @ May 20th ) [snapback]2006104[/snapback]</div>