Originally Posted by UCFNoleFan

Overrated- Tomlinson (I don't think people give that O-line as much credit as they deserve, they are an all-time great run blocking unit)... I would give runner up spots to Romo and Marion Barber.

Originally Posted by andrew001

Most Underrated
edgerrin James~he Is Awesome If He Has A O-line

Most Overrated
I Would Of Never Said This Last Year But I'm Going With ladianan Tomlinson~ He Showed Last Year That He May Be Slowing Down

Originally Posted by P-Rez25

Best Player - Randy Moss

he made a good team great, he made Tom Brady into an MVP, Bradys career high in TDs before this year was 28 now it sits at 50. Bradys career high in passing yards was 4110 and now it sits at 4806. that is a major difference. to me i can forget about the 2 years he had in Oakland because i very much doubt anyone of the top players can suceed there with Al Davis putting in his hands on everything. this guy made Daunte Culpepper look great, extended Randall Cunninhams career for a few seasons and now helping make Tom Brady look like hes Dan Marino/Peyton Manning.

Overrated - Tom Brady

im not saying the guy isnt good but everyone overrates him like hes the best QB ever. spare me the SuperBowl rings argument because the reason why he got those rings is kicking for Peyton Manning now. before this year most of his yards came from his recievers YAC. hes made a career of throwing short passes and letting the recievers do the work. yeah he has many games in which a kicker has come in to save the day but does he have any John Elway down by more than a FG game winning drives? he makes the right plays most of the time but when the pressure is on him he folds.

Originally Posted by P-Rez25

where was this "all-time great" run blocking unit in 2001 when he ran for 1236 yards and 10 TDs? what about in 2002 when he ran for 1683 yards and 14 TD? i bet they was there in 2003 when he had 1645 yards and 13 TDs? he didnt just start producing now just because the o-line play has improved. he produced from day one when the ONLY threat the Chargers had on O was in fact Tomlinson. for years he had no true #1 reciever to take the pressure off him, while constantly facing 9-10 man fronts. the guy had already run close to 9000 yards and 72 TDs before he had the record breaking season in 2006. if thats overrated please football gods, bless my team with more overated players like Tomlinson.



maybe you should have said Edgerrin James is awesome if he has Peyton Manning. James now is at best a serviceable back that can occasionally have the big game.

another thing how is Tomlinson slowing down? did you really expect that he was gonna duplicate the record year of 2006? are you really that naive? in his worst rushing year in 2004 he ran for 1335 yards on 339 attempts. this past year he ran for 1474 on 315 attempts. he ran for more yards on less attempts which tells me that he isnt slowing down but hes getting more efficient due to the whole offense improving as a whole. i mean he must REALLY be slowing down if he led the league in rushing again. do your homework before you embarass yourself

Originally Posted by P-Rez25

where was this "all-time great" run blocking unit in 2001 when he ran for 1236 yards and 10 TDs? what about in 2002 when he ran for 1683 yards and 14 TD? i bet they was there in 2003 when he had 1645 yards and 13 TDs? he didnt just start producing now just because the o-line play has improved. he produced from day one when the ONLY threat the Chargers had on O was in fact Tomlinson. for years he had no true #1 reciever to take the pressure off him, while constantly facing 9-10 man fronts. the guy had already run close to 9000 yards and 72 TDs before he had the record breaking season in 2006. if thats overrated please football gods, bless my team with more overated players like Tomlinson.

Originally Posted by UCFNoleFan

They had very good run blocking O-lines in alomst all those years, but that's beside the point. I think he is far and away the best RB in the game today, I call him the most overrated player in the NFL because people have already started calling him a top 3 all time back, which he has a long way to go before he even approaches. Right now he is in my top 10, barely... but he is the only one still playing and can easily move up if he stays healthy and keeps putting up big numbers.