Professor

any of em, lol, I have a personal hate for ricky "for who, for what" watters

__________________

Serrated Shadow

lol..sure. I only put him on there cause of his yardage totals anyway.

__________________

BU54

That's a tough list to debate. I'm glad Bo Jackson isn't there.

__________________
Bears always have and always will need a quarterback!! But not a MLB.


10-7-07 Bears 27,Packers 20
12-23-07 Bears 35, Packers 7

Serrated Shadow

yeah, i looked his stats up and couldn't believe how revered he is for such little amount of playing time.

__________________

Serrated Shadow

any more input? If not i can set up the brackets tonight

__________________

Professor

I would wait until tomorrow, to see if there is any input after the weekend.

__________________

gruntbygod

Backs drafted since 1990 that should be considered IMO

Emmit Smith
Marshal Faulk
Jerome Bettis
Terrell Davis (short career, but brilliant)
Curtis Martin
Jerome Bettis
Ladanian Tomlinson
Tiki Barber
Priest Holmes (See Davis)
Jammal Lewis (since he turned it around)
Edgerine James
Cory Dillion

Rickey Watters has the stats, but he just dint help his teams enough to be considered with the best

Guys like Eddie George, Garrison Hearst, Charlie Garner, Ricky Williams, Rudi Johnson, Shaun Alexander and a few others just dont quite rate to be considered amoung the best ever. Wheather or not the burnt out to fast (George, probobly Alexander), got hurt either too much or had lost years (Garner, Hearst) or had personal problems derail what was becoming a brilliant career (Williams)

Serrated Shadow

So, who should be on the list, Eddie George or Jammal Lewis?

__________________

gruntbygod

Lewis

George was very good, but never great

Lewis has won championships and broken records

BeastJacobs

Yeah I'm going with Jamaal Lewis on that one. And Bo Jackson was so revered because he was one of the best made running backs and one of the fastest and most powerful so maybe that's why he's so revered, cause he could have been the best. If he hadn't had that injury.

__________________