[Serrated Shadow]

Okay guys, before voting, check out the stats, the discussion, what have you. This whole point of this tournament is to learn stuff about these guys that you didn't know and maybe change your opinion of some.

Tiki Barber



Hall of Famer: No
Pro Bowls: 3 Times
All Pro: 3 Times

Years: 1997-2006

Rushing Average: 4.7
Rushing Yards: 10,449
Rushing Touchdowns: 55
1,000 yard rushing seasons: 6
Receptions: 586
Receiving Yards: 5183
Yards per reception: 8.8
Receiving TDs: 12
Fumbles: 53

Total net yards: 15,632
Total Td's: 67

New York Giants All Time leading rusher.



Herschel Walker




Hall of Famer: No
Pro Bowls: 2 Times
All Pro: 2 Times

Years: 1986-1997

Rushing Average: 4.2
Rushing Yards: 8,225
Rushing Touchdowns: 61
1,000 yard rushing seasons: 2
Receptions: 512
Receiving Yards: 4,859
Yards per reception: 9.5
Receiving TDs: 21
Fumbles: 41

Total net yards: 13,084
Total Td's: 82

[Professor]

these guys are very closely matched up. I have to give the edge to Herschel. He added that special teams element that tiki just didn't have.

[BeastJacobs]

I may not like Tiki anymore after he badmouthed the Giants but I have to say. I didn't know that he ran for 278 yards in a game.

[Serrated Shadow]

yeah, my mistake. I always copy/paste the template when i make another thread. I just forgot to erase that.

[P-Rez25]

Herschel gets my vote for the same reason Prof said, he had that special teams element that you also had to account for.